Friday, November 11, 2011

Friday Link Dump ~ 11/11/11

Left Hemispheres passed 100,000 hits this week.  Thanks to all our random visitors and faithless faithful readers.

Dominionism: A Primer on Christian Theology & American Politics The first in a multi-part series by our chief writer and intellectual masochist, Steve.  Not afraid of Dominionists you are?  You will be.  You will be.

Religious Bullying Protected by Potential New Law

Happy Birthday, Carl Sagan!

Mid-Week Rant: Hitchens & How Religion Is Like North Korea

A Response to "The God Test" “Human emotion and experience IS intrinsically meaningless. That is not the same as worthless. We live subjective lives in a material world with other subjective beings that we need to get along with in order for the whole wheel to roll. You diminish that by adding the god concept.”  --Preach brother!

After Atheism “As an atheist I am able to examine the human condition as it presents itself; not squeezed into the box of theism with a list of answers begging for corresponding questions.”

Monday Morning Quotes: Hugo Black

Morality 3: Of Objectivity & Oughtness

Sunday Morning Crazy: Cindy Jacobs "If You Care About the Environment, you are a Dominionist....  Riiiiiight.

A Freethinker is Satan’s Slave “Rationalism says man’s mind, his reason, can determine and know truth. Presuppositionalism says man’s reason is so dependent on his creator that knowledge must begin with God’s revelation of Himself.”

Pastors Challenge The Extremism Behind 'The Call: Detroit'  This is an example of moderate Christians fighting Christian extremism.  We are always asking for it, so we like to highlight it when we find it.






Report: Military Blew $1 Trillion on Weapons Since 9/11


Atheist Army Sergeant Unleashes on the Bully Known as JD the Christian Fighter Pilot



World headed for irreversible climate change in five years, IEA warns Can we please find a republican to travel the country and speak about this?  Maybe then we can stop dismissing the messenger and make a genuine attempt to solve the problem.


Fox News Lies: Obama’s Christmas Tree Tax You are going to hear about this over and over as Fox kicks off it’s annual “War on Christmas” propaganda machine.  Just remember two facts: It was initiated as a request form the National Christmas Tree Association and it began in December of 2008.  Back when Obama still had a blackberry.









Grilled Cheesus Yes, this is as real as it is awesome.





.

Wednesday, November 9, 2011

Happy Birthday, Carl Sagan!

Left Hemispheres just wanted to say happy birthday to Carl Sagan. Be sure to check out the Sagan Series, other videos and quotes in the link or label.

Mid-Week Rant: Hitchens & How Religion Is Like North Korea



via 

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

After Atheism

Paul Wallace wrote article titled Atheism is Doomed in Religion Dispatches.  It is a response to the Christian Piatt  article: Why Religious Fundamentalism Can’t Last .  Wallace’s central point is that New Atheism is a response to the rise in global fundamentalism.  That the two systems of belief are mirror images of each other and that they are the last desperate cries of dying worldviews.

“But religious fundamentalism is not the only branch attached to the dying vine of modernity. So too is the rigid scientism of the so-called New Atheists. Their sound and fury, dependent as it is on that of the fundamentalists, is more recent. It also cannot last.”

No argument from me on the first point.  Five minutes searching the term “New Atheism” will no doubt yield the 9/11 attacks to Sam Harris The End of Faith narrative.  Organized religion inspired an attack so severe that it traumatized an entire nation and gave birth to two decade long wars.  Suddenly blasphemy was a lesser evil and people began to have a platform to say out loud what many of us had been thinking but were too polite to say.  

My bone of contention is the placing of New Atheism as the polar opposite of modern fundamentalism.  These two philosophies cannot be reduced to faith vs reason.  Soul vs science (the rematch!)  I agree that NA and fundamentalism spring from the same existential questions but They are not two sides of the same coin.  Fundamentalism is usually characterized by its dogmatism.  Wallace argues that New Atheists have a dogmatic loyalty to science and that this is a conceit.  Science is humble.  It has to be because the method demands that the best theory is only as good as our ability to invalidate it.  A scientific theory, like a faith claim starts with an explanation about the universe.  From that point they diverge because the theory needs to be tested and doubted.  It needs a survive a trial by fire.  Utility outweighs ideology...eventually.  
Its not about atheism.  Atheism is just a scientific conclusion.  In most cases it is just the term I use for word economy.  I am biracial, but I often refer to myself as black.  This is not due to some unconscious need to chose a race, it is just easier because most Americans are white.  If I am talking about my race, it is usually in the context of my identify as a non-Caucasian.  An atheist is not all that I am.  It can’t be.  To believe otherwise would be to distill my identity to what I am not.  Sure, I am a New Atheist.  Maybe even an atheist apologist.  But inverse fundamentalist really doesn’t describe me.  I welcome new ideas and opposing viewpoints.  You cannot be dogmatic about trying to dis-prove your own hypothesis.

This movement of which I am a part,  this blog, this global discourse is first and foremost an intellectual pursuit.  I am a cog in this unholy machine for a good reason.  As an atheist I am able to examine the human condition as it presents itself; not squeezed into the box of theism with a list of answers begging for corresponding questions.  Religious apologists love to say that atheists are rejecting theism as a means to understanding the world  because we don’t like where it leads.  I hear this in my conversations when people imply that I am missing the intrinsic value of faith.  I recognize the value of theism in examining the human condition.  It is the most prevalent social construct  in human consciousness.  I think it is so important  that I study it, well...religiously.    I also believe that the only way to view theism objectively is through the lens of atheism.  Becoming an atheist was not a destination.  It was a necessary step to my own personal development.  I am a student of existence.  Reason does not have that visceral quality that keep the WBC out in the cold to picket a dead soldier.  Maybe New Atheism is burning too hot to sustain itself.  It doesn’t matter.  This is post-theism.  It is anything but doomed.  For the record, there will always be fundies too.  Don't say I didn't warn you.

Monday, November 7, 2011

Monday Morning Quotes: Hugo Black


In the words of Jefferson, the clause against establishment of religion by law was intended to erect 'a wall of separation between church and state.
--Everson v. Board of Education (1947)

Its first and most immediate purpose rested on the belief that a union of government and religion tends to destroy government and degrade religion.

It is my belief that there are "absolutes" in our Bill of Rights, and that they were put there on purpose by men who knew what words meant, and meant their prohibitions to be "absolute."

The "establishment of religion" clause of the First Amendment means at least this: Neither a state nor the Federal Government can set up a church. Neither can pass laws which aid one religion, aid all religions, or prefer one religion over another. Neither can force nor influence a person to go to or to remain away from church against his will or force him to profess a belief or disbelief in any religion.
--Everson v. Board of Education (1947)

The Founding Fathers gave the free press the protection it must have to bare the secrets of government and inform the people.

The Framers of the Constitution knew that free speech is the friend of change and revolution. But they also knew that it is always the deadliest enemy of tyranny.

Freedom of speech means that you shall not do something to people either for the views they express, or the words they speak or write.

Paramount among the responsibilities of a free press is the duty to prevent any part of the government from deceiving the people and sending them off to distant lands to die of foreign fevers and foreign shot and shell.

Criticism of government finds sanctuary in several portions of the 1st Amendment. It is part of the right of free speech. It embraces freedom of the press.

Our Constitution was not written in the sands to be washed away by each wave of new judges blown in by each successive political wind.

The First Amendment was added to the Constitution to stand as a guarantee that neither the power nor the prestige of the Federal Government would be used to control, support or influence the kinds of prayer the American people can say.... Under that Amendment's prohibition against governmental establishment of religion, as reinforced by the provisions of the Fourteenth Amendment, government in this country, be it state or federal, is without power to prescribe by law any particular form of prayer which is to be used as an official prayer in carrying on any program of govermentally-sponsored religious activity.
--Engel v. Vitale (1963)

The layman's constitutional view is that what he likes is constitutional and that which he doesn't like is unconstitutional.

.

Sunday, November 6, 2011

Morality 3: Of Objectivity & Oughtness


This is Part 3 in a three part series. Part 1 is Morality 1: Good Without Gods and Part 2 is Morality 2: Not-So-Good Books.



via QualiaSoup

Sunday Morning Crazy: Cindy Jacobs "If You Care About The Environment, You're A Dominionist"





This is an old tactic of the Dominionists. They either outright deny that Dominionism exists, or they conflate issues to try and softball it so it sounds benign.

“Well if everyone was Christian and lived in a perfectly harmonious Christian Nation everything would be perfect and we wouldn’t need laws.”

What they don’t tell you is that only their brand of Christianity is considered worthy of citizenship and anyone that isn’t is...well...agents of Satan possessed by demons.

So, Cindy...don’t even bother trying to softening up your approach. we can see right through you and we will always oppose you.

via RightWingWatch

.

Friday, November 4, 2011

Friday Link Dump ~ 11/4/11

Guestpost: Losing My (Liberal) Religion The return of Nick!!  Welcome back brother.

Monday Morning Quotes: Bill Hicks

Christoph Adami: Finding life we can't imagine (TED)

The Sagan Series (UPDATED Pt. 8)

Mid Week Rant ~ Henry Rollins

FRC: Pray Against Same-Sex Parents Adopting Children Thank goodness they're praying about it. I was afraid that they were going to take some action to actually stop it.


"In God We Trust" Motto To Be Reauthorized: Take Action Now! These are public employees wasting a ridiculous amount of time and money on this.  What tangible benefit could possibly come from diverting national attention from the pressing issues to this drivel?


The Great Archaeopteryx Debates Continue Relax people.  This is not a debate over whether or not Archaeopteryx existed.  Just the usual nerd banter around the labeling of any transitional form.

Gay Marriage & Church/State Separation: Civil Marriage Must Be Secular “It isn’t good enough for people to argue that same-sex marriage is against God’s will — it’s fine if churches teach this, but no government is under any obligation to legislate in a manner that is consistent with what what any church interprets God’s will to be. Marriage within a religion might be conceived as having been authored by God, but that is not and cannot be the starting basis for civil society. That would be the very essence of what it means to live in a theocracy.”  
~We have said it a thousand times on this blog: Every argument against Same-Sex Marriage is rooted in religion.  That simply cannot be the basis of a civil law in a secular society.


Adam's First Wife: The Story of Lilith Everyone should know this story.

How To Keep Your Child From Becoming An Atheist Try not to answer any questions directly. And for Baal’s sake keep the  Bible away from them if they learn to read before they are sufficiently indoctrinated.  Otherwise their natural curiosity will uncover the truth. If you must give them a bible make sure to keep it interesting. It will keep them off balance for a while.

Asteroid Lutetia is the first pristine relic of a failed planet


Fire Members Of The Congressional Prayer Caucus

China Makes Giant Leap With Space Docking

New Study Touts Success of “Praying Away the Gay” "These results do not prove that categorical change in sexual orientation is possible for everyone or anyone, but rather that meaningful shifts along a continuum that constitute real changes appear possible for some. The results do not prove that no one is harmed by the attempt to change, but rather that the attempt does not appear to be harmful on average or inherently harmful."
~Let’s translate: Not everyone was irrevocably damaged by being told that they are going to burn in Hell for all eternity.  Some were even able to report that on a sliding scale they are now more Seacrest than Simmons.

Making Sense of 7 Billion People

No one expects the Atheist Inquisition!

Something Just Exploded All Over Uranus Hee Hee.

Just a little Hitchslap to start off your weekend.



.

Sgt. Justin Griffith - Atheist in a Foxhole


RockBeyondBelief just released this video of Sergeant Justin Griffith's reenlistment ceremony titled High ranking Chaplain leaves out 'so help me god. Please read the description after the jump/under the video.





The Chaplain respectfully leaves off "so help me god" for the deployed atheist soldier's re-enlistment ceremony.

Chaplain (Colonel) Strohm is overseeing Sergeant Justin Griffith's re-enlistment ceremony. The Chaplain is a devout Christian with decades of active-duty service.

Sergeant Griffith is the Military Director for American Atheists, and is also spear-heading the groundbreaking atheist-themed festival 'Rock Beyond Belief' featuring Richard Dawkins at Fort Bragg, NC in 2012. He even coined the phrase "There are no chaplains in foxholes."

Despite all of this, these two are staunch allies - friends, even - and serve proudly as such.

This is an unheard of situation for many reasons. Not the least of which is the fact that a chaplain of such high rank is enthusiastically building this bridge. There are only a few chaplains with higher rank in the entire military.

This moment is potentially historic. The military's long-standing climate of hostility towards atheists is beginning to change. Foxhole atheists like Griffith are slamming the 'atheist closet' door shut behind them.

There are plenty of evangelical Christians inside and outside of the chaplaincy that are vocally opposed to equal treatment for atheists. But this video demonstrates the silent majority of Chaplains who really do 'get it'.

The constitution that SGT Griffith affirms an oath to serve and defend
guarantees:

1) A religion can't be favored over another...
AND
2) religion can't be favored over non-religion.

So even though these atheists aren't a religion, they still deserve equal treatment, opportunities, and access to resources.

Currently atheist groups are officially banned from meeting anywhere on post until the DoD-level Chaplaincy approves their groups (as of Nov of 2011, it's been an 11 month waiting game already, and with much hostility and interference.)

The atheists just want to meet in buildings (off-duty) and put their schedule out with the same visibility afforded to the religious groups. However, they are banned from even meeting in some gazebo until their packet is approved. They have met all obligations for such approval and are simply waiting. And waiting...

But this video is living proof that the atheist community *can* work in harmony with the chaplaincy - fulfilling the atheist's meager 'needs' with ease. Perhaps this type of progress will be mirrored across the Department of Defense.

Military atheists wont burn down the chapel after their meetings, or go out to find neighborhood babies to eat. They simply want to identify and 'fellowship' with their community. Like Christian / Buddhist / Muslim / Jewish / Mormon / Wiccan soldiers already get, the atheists just want the same level of respect.

[pro-tip: this does not mean 'atheism will be a religion' or any such nonsense. Atheism IS non-religion, and nothing can change that. It is, however, a 'religious preference' (an Army term) and the Chaplaincy *must* support all religious preferences.]

"Foxhole atheists are fighting for your rights, please return the favor."
- Justin Griffith
Military Director for American Atheists

Twitter: @RckBeyondBelief
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/MilitaryAtheist/
Blog: http://freethoughtblogs.com/RockBeyondBelief/

.

Thursday, November 3, 2011

Guestpost: Losing My (Liberal) Religion

 


I have been promising Steve that I would do this write-up since I gave the sermon back in August, but I’m a horrible procrastinator. And, the fact is, that writing this forced me to confront some truths that I’ve known were coming for quite awhile.

I’ve been a Unitarian Universalist for a few years now, and I’ve been fairly active from the start. I’m a member of the Worship Committee, helping to steer the topics for each week, and as a Worship Associate I have helped to run the services. I’ve given sermons on military chaplaincy, the Winter Solstice and its extra-religious significance, and the one you can listen to (embedded below) on religious tolerance versus religious pluralism. I have even set myself on a course to become an ordained UU minister (codenamed “Operation Pogo Pope”), so that I could become an atheist military chaplain and provide support to non-theist service members in a way that I never had during my 12 years in the service. My involvement with the UU Church is probably coming to an end.

Originally, I was going to give a sermon on punk rock as a social justice movement. Then the massacre in Norway happened. I changed my topic to “Religious Tolerance versus Religious Pluralism.” While I was putting the service together and writing the sermon, I struggled not to rail against religion in general and give an “evangelical” New Atheist lecture. The service that was conducted was very well received, which the New Atheist one wouldn’t have been. I didn’t record the service in its entirety, because I felt that would be a violation of trust, as it includes a lot of member participation (singing, the sharing of joys and sorrows, etc.). There are going to be parts that are going to raise some hackles. For instance, the “frivolous lawsuit” by American Atheists over the I-beam “cross” found at Ground Zero. No, I do not think the cross should be included. Yes, I think that David Silverman is a dick. I wish the lawsuit had been brought by the FFRF, or some other freethought organization, rather than those yammering, publicity-obsessed idiots at American Atheists.

I’m not going to expound on the sermon I gave too much, although I’ll gladly reply to any comments made on it. Really, this post is about what I went through when writing it, and the results of having to review my (then) current stance on things.

Unitarian Universalists, while evolving from two Christian denominations, are now a fairly diverse lot. They are accepting of all the groups I mentioned in the sermon (atheists, agnostics, pantheists, deists, Jews, Christians, Muslims, Sikhs, Rastafarian, Pastafarian, Baha’i, etc.), plus various personal innovations. UU’s truly do believe in freedom of conscience. Their Seven Principles are to be lauded, as they are a fine representation of humanist thought. The problem is I just can’t do it anymore. I can’t nod and smile as someone talks about how gods and goddesses of long dead religions have talked to them. I can’t indulge liberal followers of the Abrahamic faiths that believe that they have a god of love and compassion, and that the extremists are misinterpreting the horrific texts that they all look to for guidance. I can’t in good conscience allow my son to sit in religious education classes where he will be taught about the heroes of the Bible and Bhagavad-Gita. The fact is that most of the people in these books either never existed, or are cultural inflations. It’s bad enough that Sunday Schools teach white-washed versions of their scripture, but do I really want to back the teaching of liberal interpretations of these figures? The UU church I’ve been part of rotates through an annual curriculum of “world religion” and the Bible. The Bible program is called “Biblelodeon”, and is described on various UU sites,

Bibleodeon introduces Hebrew and Christian scriptures by presenting the best-known Hebrew and Christian stories with such props as the Bibleodeon microphone and such interactive challenges as investigating the Cain-Abel crime scene. Participants act in 11 amusing playlets with characters like the Fatted Calf, illustrate a time line, keep doodle books, give awards to outstanding biblical women, and more. They explore connections between biblical events and Unitarian Universalist principles, between biblical ideas and their own lives. They experience the Bible as one of many wonderful UU sources.

When I was a kid I remember learning about Lot, Jesus and Abraham, but not about giving your daughters to be gang-raped (Genesis 19:6), an anti-family psychopath (Luke 14:26 and 19:27), nor a man willing to kill and mutilate his child (Genesis 22: 1-19). The UU versions are set on an even lighter note. Why would I let my child be taught to revere the people in these stories? They’re monsters! Children are taught sugarcoated versions of these horrific tales, and many as adults continue to believe them. This is where moderate religionists come from, and why when confronted with violent acts committed by fundamentalists, they are able to say, with a clear conscience, that the “extremists” are distorting their religion.

Hemant Mehta recently reposted on Friendly Atheist a post from Elizabeth Joy’s blog. While I agree with the values she has set out to teach her children, I disagree on a major point. She says,

They know that some people believe that there is a “magical” being or beings called gods. They’ve also heard about reincarnation and that some people believe that our souls keep coming back as different living things (Carmen really likes this one and wants to come back as a bird). They have been to church and temple and understand that some people go there all the time to talk to (and about) their gods. They know that people wear different outfits, and that sometimes these are based on the rules of their respective gods.

What they have NOT heard is that any of these beliefs or practices is “wrong.” Just different. They also have not yet been told that some people believe that others should be hurt or killed because they believe something different. I don’t want to scare them when they are still so young, after all….”
This is moral and intellectual cowardice, plain and simple. Those religious beliefs are wrong. They are wrong about the morals that should govern a society (beliefs on sexuality, genital mutilation and slavery), they are historically wrong (Hebrew enslavement and exodus, lost tribes in the Americas, and who wrote their sacred texts), and they are wrong about the way in which the universe works (the structure of the universe, the age of the universe, and the theory of evolution). They could not be more wrong about everything. If there ever is a god or creator to be proved, the current and past religions would still be wrong, for these very same reasons. I will not allow my children to be misled by taking a hands-off approach on material truth. This is essentially giving “equal time” to clearly incorrect and irrational concepts of reality during the formative years of a child’s life, just as the creationists want. The Earth is not flat, it’s not the center of the universe, it is not on the back of a turtle or elephants; the sky is not held up by a titan, it is not a firmament separating two bodies of water; life was not created in its present form, there is no evidence for reincarnation or immortality of a spirit. Instilling in our youth every person’s right to a free consciousness is not the same as turning your head and leaving them in ambiguity.

I have come to grips with the fact that I am a New Atheist. I do not see any redeeming characteristics in religion, and in fact I see that it is a poison to our species. My beliefs will change with new scientific discoveries, but not based on the supernatural teachings of primitive societies. Religion is not just humanity’s least accomplishment; it is its greatest failure. It is a failure of reason, a failure of conscience. In time, it will be our greatest shame.




Monday, October 31, 2011

Monday Morning Quotes: Bill Hicks


"How do I know the Bible isn't the word of God? Well if it was the word of God it would be clear and easy to understand...considering God was the creator of LANGUAGE!"

“A lot of Christians wear crosses around their necks. You think when Jesus comes back he ever wants to see a fucking cross? It's like going up to Jackie Onassis wearing a rifle pendant.”

“I love the Pope, I love seeing him in his Pope-Mobile, his three feet of bullet proof plexi-glass. That's faith in action folks! You know he's got God on his side.”

“You ever noticed how people who believe in Creationism look really unevolved? You ever noticed that? Eyes real close together, eyebrow ridges, big furry hands and feet. "I believe God created me in one day" Yeah, looks like He rushed it.”

“You believe the world's 12 thousand years old? "That's right." Okay I got one word to ask you, a one word question, ready? "Uh huh." Dinosaurs. You know the world's 12 thousand years old and dinosaurs existed, they existed in that time, you'd think it would have been mentioned in the fucking Bible at some point. "And lo Jesus and the disciples walked to Nazareth. But the trail was blocked by a giant brontosaurus...with a splinter in his paw. And O the disciples did run a shriekin': 'What a big fucking lizard, Lord!' But Jesus was unafraid and he took the splinter from the brontosaurus's paw and the big lizard became his friend.”

“People ask me what I think about that woman priest thing. What, a woman priest? Women priests. Great, great. Now there's priests of both sexes I don't listen to.”

“Today a young man on acid realized that all matter is mearly energy condensed through a slow vibration, we are all one consciousness experiencing itself subjectively, life is only a dream and we are the imaginations of ourselves. Here's Tom with the weather.”



Screw this...just watch the videos in the Bill Hicks tag.

.